Why You Can’t Sue Apple If You Eat Your Ipod

product liabilityNot too long ago someone mentioned that my recent post “Where were you the day Twinkies died?” was just one of the many plays on Twinkies death and rebirth. One of the most notable is Twinkie: Rest in Peeps, the winning entry in the Washington Post annual Peeps diorama contest. It featured the funeral of the Twinkie in a coffin with bunny and chick mourners in the pews and depicted on the “stained glass” windows of the church. Although Peep dioramas are good any time of the year, I love Halloween themed Peep dioramas. One of my favorites is the 2012 entry complete with Peeps dressing up for Halloween as the Flintstones, Batman, and Borat, a movie character known for his “mankini” or skimpy swimsuit as featured in the GWU magazine.

product liabilityApparently, Borat was a “challenge” as it is hard to paint chest hair on a Peep. This year is the 60th anniversary of Peeps, and while I’m sure a lot went into the research and development of the product, I doubt being “chest hair paintable” was a major concern when they were shaping the marshmallow chicks and bunnies.

Just Born, the company that makes Peeps, claims to manufacture enough Peeps to circle the Earth twice EVERY year. You’d think we’d all be in a sugar coma from all those marshmallows, but it’s a little known fact that one-third of all Peeps are not actually eaten. When Peeps were created, no one intended Peeps dioramas would become part of our pop culture.

I did a quick check to see if anyone has ever sued Just Born over a Peeps diorama, since that’s not really their intended use. Surprisingly enough, nobody ever has. But it made me think of product liability cases and what happens when a consumer uses the product in an unintended way.

What is product liability?

Product liability is the area of the law dealing with claims of personal injury, property damage or economic harm arising from the design, manufacture, distribution or sale of a product. These types of claims are generally prosecuted under at least one of three theories:

  • Negligence: A product manufacturer, distributor, or seller failed to provide a standard of care (i.e., was negligent) in the design or manufacture of a product that a reasonably prudent person should have exercised under the same or similar circumstances.
  • Breach of Warranty: A product manufacturer, distributor, or seller made an express or implied promise about the product that the consumer relied upon to his/her detriment.
  • Strict Liability: Most states have adopted some version of strict liability, which means one who sells any product in a defective condition that is “unreasonably dangerous” to the user may be subject to liability for personal injury or property damage caused by the product defect even if the seller exercised all possible care (meaning the seller was not negligent) and the consumer did not enter into a contractual relationship with the seller.

Note that these are very basic definitions; the actual theories are much more detailed and complex.

Product Misuse is a Defense

product liabilityOn the other hand, a product manufacturer has a defense of product misuse. Product misuse means the product was used in a way that was not intended, reasonably anticipated or expected by the seller, or not reasonably foreseeable to the seller. Product misuse can occur where a consumer fails to follow directions or uses the product in contravention of a legally sufficient warning like the instructions and warnings on the label. A good example is you can’t make a case against Apple for indigestion if you ignore the warning label “Do not eat iPod shuffle.”

Honestly, that warning makes me think twice that it would be “reasonably foreseeable” that Apple customers would try to eat their iPods—really? Just FYI, warning labels are not a requirement for an obvious misuse of the product.

Want to know more? Learn how to protect your company at our free presentation Insider Tips to Protect Your Business on November 11, 2013. This will be the last time we’ll be presenting it for free! Contact Me for more information.

Share This

Share this post with your friends!